what we do

For Brands

Join us

Content we're proud of

Blog

6 Biggest Challenges in Influencer Marketing & How to Overcome Them

July 31, 2024
Jasmine Walters

Influencer marketing has taken the world by storm, revolutionising how brands connect with their audiences. 

What was once a niche strategy is now a powerhouse, bringing authenticity and relatability to marketing in ways traditional advertising can only dream of. 

But, as with any game-changing tool, influencer marketing comes with its own set of challenges. 

From finding the perfect influencers to proving ROI, these hurdles can seem intimidating. But fear not! At People Have Influence, we’re here to guide you through the maze. 

Let’s dive into the six biggest challenges brand managers face in influencer marketing and discover how to tackle them head-on. Ready to turn those challenges into opportunities? Let's get started!

Challenge #1

“I don’t know how to onboard influencers so that they follow the brief.”

There’s nothing more frustrating than an influencer missing the brief. It’s not just a headache for brand managers; it’s also a let-down for influencers who want the campaign to succeed as much as you do.. But guess what? There are strategies that can easily prevent this. 

Winning Strategies:

  • Create a Clear Influencer Brief: Think of the brief as your campaign’s blueprint. Be precise and detailed—outline your campaign goals, key messages, content guidelines, and deliverables. The clearer the brief, the better the influencer can deliver.
  • Maintain Honest and Open Communication: Keep the lines of communication open. Regular check-ins and honest dialogue can prevent misunderstandings and ensure everyone is on the same page.
  • Balance Creative Freedom and Branded Script: While it’s essential to get your brand’s message across, giving influencers some creative freedom can lead to more authentic and relatable content, that leads to audience engaging with the CTA. Find that sweet spot between guidance and flexibility. We find that giving creative freedom in the form of content direction can be the secret sauce here.

Challenge #2

“I want to work with influencers but I don’t have the time to manage them properly.”

Juggling internal responsibilities while managing influencer relationships can be a real challenge. But neglecting this aspect can derail even the best-laid plans.

You can have the best influencer in the world on your campaign, however, if you do not have the resources to look after the relationship, you may not be maximising the collaboration for all it’s potential. 

Pro Tips:

  • Delegate Tasks: Don’t try to do it all yourself. Assign a dedicated team member or hire a specialised agency (like us ;)) to handle influencer relations. This ensures consistent communication and holistic oversight.
  • Automate Processes: Utilise influencer marketing platforms to streamline your campaign management. From influencer discovery to performance tracking, automation can save you loads of time whilst still ensuring the influencers feel looked after on a personal level. 
  • Prioritise Regular Updates: Once you’ve delegated, schedule periodic check-ins to stay informed about campaign progress without getting bogged down in the details.

At P.H.I Whether our brand partners have experience with influencer marketing or not, we pride ourselves on making the brand team feel comfortable and confident - every step of the way. 

- The project management and people management aspect of influencer marketing is what we do best. 

Our goal is to ensure we remove the admin of people management from our brand partners; however, still give the talent the attention they deserve to ensure they produce quality content with the results to show for it. 

As the Brand Marketer at TFG expressed: “I particularly enjoy how the project is handled [by P.H.I]. There is a lot of effort involved from the selection process to reporting.”

Challenge #3

“I want to work with big influencers but they didn’t get enough engagement.”

Teaming up with big influencers is tempting due to their extensive reach, but without engagement, your brand message might fall flat. On the other hand, smaller influencers can drive higher engagement but may lack the reach. Finding the balance is the key to a successful and intentional campaign. 

Success Tactics:

  • Define Your Objectives: Are you aiming for reach and awareness, conversions or engagement? Clarifying this will help you choose the right influencers in order to meet your brand goals and online KPI’s.
  • Assess Brand Fit: Ensure the influencer’s online presence and interests align with your brand’s ‘personality.’ A partnership where both parties share the same values is a recipe for success. Remember, a perfect match is more important than a large following. Look further than the number of followers and likes. Likes do not equal money. 
  • Mix It Up: Combine macro and micro-influencers to balance reach and engagement. This hybrid approach can amplify your campaign’s effectiveness and reach diverse audiences while remaining authentic.

At P.H.I we pride ourselves on customising each and every influencer strategy according to our clients brand goals and campaign objectives. The level of detail we go into in order to suggest a strategy is worth it to us [and our brand partners appreciate this detail] as it ensures we are set up for success, before we even begin. 

This is why 95% of our clients return after a once off campaign. We don’t tell them, we show them.

Challenge #4

“I want to work with influencers, but how do I know they create conversions?”

We can almost guarantee that conversions are amongst your brand’s marketing goals. Ensuring influencers drive conversions requires thorough vetting and smart strategy—something that often requires industry experience and expertise as these insights are not available to the public and likes do not equal money, nor total following size. It’s all about their engagement and brand fit

Insider Secrets:

  • Vet Influencers AND Their Audience: Don’t just vet the influencer—vet their audience too! Dive deep into the influencer’s follower demographics and make sure their audience matches your target market. From location, to gender, to age and more. 
  • Craft Enticing CTAs: Develop compelling calls-to-action that encourage followers to take the next step, whether it’s visiting your website or making a purchase. Direct them to where you desire. 
  • Track Performance: Use tracking links and promo codes to measure the direct impact of influencer content on conversions is one of the best ways to see live ROI. Data doesn’t lie!

Backed by over 6 years of experience in influencer marketing, we take pride in our campaign performance. As one of our influencers said after working on a OneCart campaign, “The thing I liked most about this campaign was the ability to be creative and create content that I love. Keep doing what you’re doing. You guys rock”.

Challenge #5

“I want to try influencer marketing but how do I show ROI?”

Speaking of data, demonstrating return on investment [ROI] is crucial for justifying your marketing spend. Luckily, there are plenty of metrics to showcase the value of your influencer campaigns.

Power Moves:

  • Measure Engagement Rates: Keep an eye on likes, comments, and shares. These metrics reveal how well the content resonates with your target audience.
  • Monitor Impressions and Clicks: Analyse the number of views and clicks to understand the reach and interest generated by the campaign.
  • Analyse Conversions: Use analytics tools to follow the customer journey from influencer content to purchase. This way, you can see exactly how your sales are being driven.
  • Consider Audience Sentiment: Don’t overlook qualitative feedback. Monitor comments and overall sentiment to understand how your campaign is being perceived by the audience.

Challenge #6

“I want to work with influencers but I do not know where to start.”

Just like starting anything new, diving into influencer marketing can feel like stepping into the unknown. But with the right approach, it can become a powerful part of your strategy. 

After working with Yaga for over 3 years, a brand that was not known to the SA audience, is now one of the top 30 downloaded apps in South Africa, allowing girls to sell their previously loved items and make an extra income. They ONLY used influencer marketing for 3 years to infiltrate the market and safe to say, we succeeded. 

At People Have Influence, we take the guesswork out of influencer marketing. Imagine focusing solely on your brand goals while we handle all the project and people management. From concept and ideation to sourcing, vetting, and profiling the perfect influencers, we cover every detail to align with your brand’s objectives. We’re dedicated to working closely with you to deliver the ROI and results you need. Plus, with our live data-tracking  dashboard, you’ll stay updated with real-time results throughout the campaign. Transparency is essential to us, and we’re committed to earning your trust with results that speak for themselves.

A brand partner we’ve had the pleasure of collaborating with on a number of outstanding campaigns said: “I love working with PHI! The team is super knowledgeable, and I trust them to take my brand’s ideas and elevate them authentically through influencers.” - Marketing Manager at Adidas ZA.

Get In Touch with Us!

Excited to get started? Let us handle the nitty-gritty that normally brings you headaches and wastes your time. If you’re a brand looking for exposure and creative campaigns, let’s chat and make magic together! Don’t forget, it costs nothing to inquire. 😉

If you like this blog, you will like these as well:
Goal Setting For Influencer Marketing Campaigns
Goal Setting For Influencer Marketing Campaigns
We’ve Got Your Influencer Marketing Strategy for 2025 Sorted.
We’ve Got Your Influencer Marketing Strategy for 2025 Sorted.
Unleashing Your Brand’s Potential with the Creator Economy in 2024
Unleashing Your Brand’s Potential with the Creator Economy in 2024

6 Biggest Challenges in Influencer Marketing & How to Overcome Them

July 31, 2024
Jasmine Walters

Influencer marketing has taken the world by storm, revolutionising how brands connect with their audiences. 

What was once a niche strategy is now a powerhouse, bringing authenticity and relatability to marketing in ways traditional advertising can only dream of. 

But, as with any game-changing tool, influencer marketing comes with its own set of challenges. 

From finding the perfect influencers to proving ROI, these hurdles can seem intimidating. But fear not! At People Have Influence, we’re here to guide you through the maze. 

Let’s dive into the six biggest challenges brand managers face in influencer marketing and discover how to tackle them head-on. Ready to turn those challenges into opportunities? Let's get started!

Challenge #1

“I don’t know how to onboard influencers so that they follow the brief.”

There’s nothing more frustrating than an influencer missing the brief. It’s not just a headache for brand managers; it’s also a let-down for influencers who want the campaign to succeed as much as you do.. But guess what? There are strategies that can easily prevent this. 

Winning Strategies:

  • Create a Clear Influencer Brief: Think of the brief as your campaign’s blueprint. Be precise and detailed—outline your campaign goals, key messages, content guidelines, and deliverables. The clearer the brief, the better the influencer can deliver.
  • Maintain Honest and Open Communication: Keep the lines of communication open. Regular check-ins and honest dialogue can prevent misunderstandings and ensure everyone is on the same page.
  • Balance Creative Freedom and Branded Script: While it’s essential to get your brand’s message across, giving influencers some creative freedom can lead to more authentic and relatable content, that leads to audience engaging with the CTA. Find that sweet spot between guidance and flexibility. We find that giving creative freedom in the form of content direction can be the secret sauce here.

Challenge #2

“I want to work with influencers but I don’t have the time to manage them properly.”

Juggling internal responsibilities while managing influencer relationships can be a real challenge. But neglecting this aspect can derail even the best-laid plans.

You can have the best influencer in the world on your campaign, however, if you do not have the resources to look after the relationship, you may not be maximising the collaboration for all it’s potential. 

Pro Tips:

  • Delegate Tasks: Don’t try to do it all yourself. Assign a dedicated team member or hire a specialised agency (like us ;)) to handle influencer relations. This ensures consistent communication and holistic oversight.
  • Automate Processes: Utilise influencer marketing platforms to streamline your campaign management. From influencer discovery to performance tracking, automation can save you loads of time whilst still ensuring the influencers feel looked after on a personal level. 
  • Prioritise Regular Updates: Once you’ve delegated, schedule periodic check-ins to stay informed about campaign progress without getting bogged down in the details.

At P.H.I Whether our brand partners have experience with influencer marketing or not, we pride ourselves on making the brand team feel comfortable and confident - every step of the way. 

- The project management and people management aspect of influencer marketing is what we do best. 

Our goal is to ensure we remove the admin of people management from our brand partners; however, still give the talent the attention they deserve to ensure they produce quality content with the results to show for it. 

As the Brand Marketer at TFG expressed: “I particularly enjoy how the project is handled [by P.H.I]. There is a lot of effort involved from the selection process to reporting.”

Challenge #3

“I want to work with big influencers but they didn’t get enough engagement.”

Teaming up with big influencers is tempting due to their extensive reach, but without engagement, your brand message might fall flat. On the other hand, smaller influencers can drive higher engagement but may lack the reach. Finding the balance is the key to a successful and intentional campaign. 

Success Tactics:

  • Define Your Objectives: Are you aiming for reach and awareness, conversions or engagement? Clarifying this will help you choose the right influencers in order to meet your brand goals and online KPI’s.
  • Assess Brand Fit: Ensure the influencer’s online presence and interests align with your brand’s ‘personality.’ A partnership where both parties share the same values is a recipe for success. Remember, a perfect match is more important than a large following. Look further than the number of followers and likes. Likes do not equal money. 
  • Mix It Up: Combine macro and micro-influencers to balance reach and engagement. This hybrid approach can amplify your campaign’s effectiveness and reach diverse audiences while remaining authentic.

At P.H.I we pride ourselves on customising each and every influencer strategy according to our clients brand goals and campaign objectives. The level of detail we go into in order to suggest a strategy is worth it to us [and our brand partners appreciate this detail] as it ensures we are set up for success, before we even begin. 

This is why 95% of our clients return after a once off campaign. We don’t tell them, we show them.

Challenge #4

“I want to work with influencers, but how do I know they create conversions?”

We can almost guarantee that conversions are amongst your brand’s marketing goals. Ensuring influencers drive conversions requires thorough vetting and smart strategy—something that often requires industry experience and expertise as these insights are not available to the public and likes do not equal money, nor total following size. It’s all about their engagement and brand fit

Insider Secrets:

  • Vet Influencers AND Their Audience: Don’t just vet the influencer—vet their audience too! Dive deep into the influencer’s follower demographics and make sure their audience matches your target market. From location, to gender, to age and more. 
  • Craft Enticing CTAs: Develop compelling calls-to-action that encourage followers to take the next step, whether it’s visiting your website or making a purchase. Direct them to where you desire. 
  • Track Performance: Use tracking links and promo codes to measure the direct impact of influencer content on conversions is one of the best ways to see live ROI. Data doesn’t lie!

Backed by over 6 years of experience in influencer marketing, we take pride in our campaign performance. As one of our influencers said after working on a OneCart campaign, “The thing I liked most about this campaign was the ability to be creative and create content that I love. Keep doing what you’re doing. You guys rock”.

Challenge #5

“I want to try influencer marketing but how do I show ROI?”

Speaking of data, demonstrating return on investment [ROI] is crucial for justifying your marketing spend. Luckily, there are plenty of metrics to showcase the value of your influencer campaigns.

Power Moves:

  • Measure Engagement Rates: Keep an eye on likes, comments, and shares. These metrics reveal how well the content resonates with your target audience.
  • Monitor Impressions and Clicks: Analyse the number of views and clicks to understand the reach and interest generated by the campaign.
  • Analyse Conversions: Use analytics tools to follow the customer journey from influencer content to purchase. This way, you can see exactly how your sales are being driven.
  • Consider Audience Sentiment: Don’t overlook qualitative feedback. Monitor comments and overall sentiment to understand how your campaign is being perceived by the audience.

Challenge #6

“I want to work with influencers but I do not know where to start.”

Just like starting anything new, diving into influencer marketing can feel like stepping into the unknown. But with the right approach, it can become a powerful part of your strategy. 

After working with Yaga for over 3 years, a brand that was not known to the SA audience, is now one of the top 30 downloaded apps in South Africa, allowing girls to sell their previously loved items and make an extra income. They ONLY used influencer marketing for 3 years to infiltrate the market and safe to say, we succeeded. 

At People Have Influence, we take the guesswork out of influencer marketing. Imagine focusing solely on your brand goals while we handle all the project and people management. From concept and ideation to sourcing, vetting, and profiling the perfect influencers, we cover every detail to align with your brand’s objectives. We’re dedicated to working closely with you to deliver the ROI and results you need. Plus, with our live data-tracking  dashboard, you’ll stay updated with real-time results throughout the campaign. Transparency is essential to us, and we’re committed to earning your trust with results that speak for themselves.

A brand partner we’ve had the pleasure of collaborating with on a number of outstanding campaigns said: “I love working with PHI! The team is super knowledgeable, and I trust them to take my brand’s ideas and elevate them authentically through influencers.” - Marketing Manager at Adidas ZA.

Get In Touch with Us!

Excited to get started? Let us handle the nitty-gritty that normally brings you headaches and wastes your time. If you’re a brand looking for exposure and creative campaigns, let’s chat and make magic together! Don’t forget, it costs nothing to inquire. 😉

If you like this blog, you will like these as well:
Goal Setting For Influencer Marketing Campaigns
Goal Setting For Influencer Marketing Campaigns
We’ve Got Your Influencer Marketing Strategy for 2025 Sorted.
We’ve Got Your Influencer Marketing Strategy for 2025 Sorted.
Unleashing Your Brand’s Potential with the Creator Economy in 2024
Unleashing Your Brand’s Potential with the Creator Economy in 2024